At last, it’s time to talk about the latest ‘n greatest Facebook fad-turned-custom: The posting of a list of visitation rules or “light suggestions” by parents when they have a new baby, which is sort of like the “open letter” of parent overshare. To some, these lists are an easy way to communicate information to people who might want to visit the baby or lend a hand. To others, the lists are a narcissistic and passive-aggressive approach to telling family and friends what, and what not, to do. You can probably guess which side of the debate I’m on.
Every now and then, new comments appear on old visitation rulesblog posts that attempt to justify them. Usually the argument is that some parents have morons for friends and their relatives are all assholes who chain smoke over bassinets, so those people need instruction, they’re going to drop by unannounced, etc. But my feeling is, the majority of people aren’t that stupid, so why not just email or text the ones who are and politely ask them not to come over after a three-day bender with a raging cold? Why post a list of obvious rules on Facebook when you could address a small handful of people more privately?
What it comes down to is this: The notes and “tips” are tools that parents use to remind everyone what time it is — Baby Time. They want the meal train, the organic baby merch, and, if it’s not too much trouble, they wouldn’t mind if you cleaned their house, too. Sure, some people are just trying to ensure that the folks who visit are healthy and their hands are clean, but even then, there’s a sense of, “We know how much you’ve been dying to meet our perfect creation, but first you’re going to have to follow a few basic orders.” Sometimes it’s not only the parents who are annoying, but their friends who are in charge of helping, too. We already know "it takes a village" (more on that in my Mommyish column), but a lot of the requests seem to translate to “Mr. and Mrs. Obnoxious seek your money and attention,” rather than, “If you can help out, great! If not, they’d still love to see you if you want to meet the baby.” I’m not saying these lists or requests are completely ineffective and rude; I’ve just never once heard someone say, “My friend/co-worker/relative’s list of ‘new baby rules’ was SUPER helpful.” In fact, since the column ran, I received this email:
![image]()
To that end, let’s check out some examples of the ways that people talk about newborn visitation online:
1. Dinner Time
![image]()
This closed group memo isn’t necessarily out of line, but something about it makes me want to leave a casserole made of pizza dough, steak, golden raisins, and green peppers sitting in the new parents’ mailbox. The way “please” is used in the last line of the note is akin to your boss saying, “Please don’t be offended if I don’t ask you to come back to work ever again,” or the bank saying, “Please don’t be offended if we foreclose on your house.” I understand it’s a “polite suggestion” to dumbfucks who come over and never leave, but it also implies that people WANT to come over and never leave. It’s the Catch-22 of visitation note demands suggestions.
2. Germ Jerks
![image]()
I hope people are more considerate around newborns, too, Mel. Thankfully, folks like you and Mandy are members of the National Germs Conspiracy Coalition, which prevents evil germs from spreading by educating all of the un-well idiots who just don’t friggin’ think !!!! Can you believe some people have no idea there they’re capable of spreading illness until someone on Facebook lectures them? Sad, but true!
3. Offers To Help and So On
![image]()
![image]()
Much like I can’t pick a favorite line from "Kindergarten Cop," I’d be hard-pressed to pick a favorite request, or even word/phrase, from Nate’s extensive list of charmers (a few lines of which the submitter accidentally cut off, but are mostly understood). Upon first reflection, I’m inclined to say that using the word “fetch” in any context as it refers to voluntary human assistance is the most fucked up thing a person could include in a list like this. But then there’s Nate’s request that a friend physically GO TO IKEA — which, despite its eye-candy interiors and free Swedish meatballs, is hell on earth — to purchase Nate some fucking bookshelves (the one with the "Swedish-sounding name"), and then maybe come over and help assemble them in-between holding the baby, cooking a veggie lasagna, and braiding Nate’s back hair. No thanks.
I think I’ll just (eventually) fetch a middle finger and wave it in Nate and Angelica’s direction. Also: “language-ness” is hipster douchebag for “culture.” Since this submission is so old, I’m curious how Nate and Angelica’s plan to be “quite anxious parents” has held up. Something tells me they’re still deeply committed to that pretentious parenting model.
4. NOT a Joke
![image]()
Come over! Clean our shit! Bake us stuff! Take the “Rules” Challenge and see how much you can get done in a mere 45 minutes! We, The Asshole Clan, are hoping that everyone who comes over for the first two weeks of our baby’s life will be able to accomplish the following in the allotted visitation window:
1. Meet and greet with the baby. This should take 2-4 minutes TOPS because we don’t want to take away from your chores time.
2. Hand us the food you made! Is it nachos? Is it banana bread like your grandma used to make? Did you lace some chowder with rat poison to play a dirty trick on us for writing this offensive list of demands? Haha! We won’t know until we eat it, will we?
3. Choose a task on the refrigerator. As you’re cooking, cleaning, or changing our precious angel’s dirty diaper, we will openly critique you. This isn’t because we’re super picky, it’s because we think it’s fun. This is OUR TIME to make a slave out of YOU!
4. Complete as many tasks as you can until our timer goes off and you leave. The timer ringing is your cue to quickly gather your belongings (not all of the thoughtful gifts you brought us, but everything else! :), and quietly exit our home without causing a scene. Silently wave goodbye or offer a respectful salute. Please don’t be offended if you run into any car troubles on the way home and we don’t answer the phone or provide any assistance. We are nesting!
5. So Get Over It.
![image]()
I was with Orange (in an eye-roll sort of way) until I got to “Braydan.” After that, my brain exploded and I continued on with Maury-like delight. Sure, this list is full of mostly reasonable requests, but by the time I got to Green’s winning comment, I just felt disappointed that I couldn’t witness the fallout from someone breaking one of Orange’s rules. I can only imagine it would contain more awesome lines like, “I’m the parent, so get over it.”
Funny how before a person has a baby, lines like that sound absurdly high-handed, but immediately after, they roll right off the tongue and are met with ardent praise from other parents. Fellow ‘rents say stuff like, “That’s right, you TELL your family how it’s going to be now that you have a BABY!”, or, “If your relatives don’t like your rules, then TOUGH! That’s their problem!" Kudos to Green for boldly posting an acerbic two-sentence reply, and with a smiley no less. That’s sass.
6. A Thousand Times Yes
![image]()
Now we’ve arrived at the most crucial, yet increasingly irrelevant, question surrounding visitation rules: Which came first: the Facebook status update or the blog post? Who were the original geniuses that inspired thousands of parents to think this was a good idea? Can they stop now? Nothing against Scary Mommy — this was a guest post that went viral, and I think Jill Smokler is hilarious — but we’re talking about a list of rules that includes “tips” like:
- "I hate to say it, but if you can’t afford to buy her a decent lunch, then you need to consider whether you can really afford to hold this baby."
- "Does Mama have some pulled pork or a rack of short ribs simmering in the crock-pot when you arrive? Don’t you dare accept any of it if she offers. She is being polite and you are not actually a guest. You are an intruder."
- “The hallmark of a truly excellent friend is one who will knock quietly, put the food on the front porch, then get in the car and drive away.”
- "You can have some water if you get it yourself."
- “Don’t make Mama waste a stamp graciously thanking you for some random thing you dug up at Tuesday Morning that she never wanted in the first place.”
- “Load them smart because you know how much we hate it when the dishwasher is loaded wrong.”
- "Babies grow fast. Use your brain."
This exercise in “humor etiquette” hurts our chances of ever escaping demanding visitation lists from showing up in our newsfeeds or inboxes. It is a blight on the internet, despite being shared by 346K people women who agree with it. And, in fact, it’s those 346K sanctimommies to whom I dedicate this website. Them, and the thousands of people who shared this next example (the response to which is so long I had to divide it into two images):
7. “Societal Expectations”
![image]()
![image]()
Matt appears to have a problem with the CAPS lock button, among about a billion other things. Why is he acting so hostile toward Jacqueline? All she expressed was what ‘the other half’ is thinking, which is that lists that offer advice like “Remember that the purpose of the visit is for you to help the family, not for you to spend time with the baby.” are bullshit. And even though it may seem like parents are conquering the proverbial battle between sidewalk and stroller, some of us are willing to get our feet trampled to make ourselves heard. Johanna’s colorful remark that her friends “are welcome to say congratulations from the porch” makes me feel like dumping a pan of chicken and dumplings on her face, and in the future, if a friend ever says something similar to me, I may do just that.
![congratulations smiley congratulations smiley]()
It must be stated for the record that not all parents are like this, obviously. But those who are should recognize one very important thing: No one cares about your baby as much as you do. Stop telling everyone what to do. We will wash our hands. We will take our cold and flu medications. We will stop playing with knives around young children. Just please stop sending visitation rules memos. We’ve already gotten them. All of them.
To read even more examples of visitation rules and requests, check out my column on Mommyish! I tackle tough questions like, “WTF constitutes a “village” anymore?” and, “Are some demands are more acceptable than others?” Groundbreaking stuff.
Related: Baby Shower Gift, Hospital Gift, After-Home Baby Gift
(submitted by Anonymous)